The HEMI tick on a 5.7 or 6.4 Ram, Grand Cherokee, Charger, Durango or 300 is almost always a failing MDS lifter — not a new engine. Dealers quote north of $5,000 and sometimes a whole engine; Cars With Fares does the lifter and camshaft job right in your driveway across the GTA for a flat quote first. Call or text 647-450-0406.

You took your Ram, Grand Cherokee, Charger, Durango or 300 in for a tick, and the service advisor handed you a number with a comma in it — usually somewhere north of $5,000, and on a 6.4 truck I've seen them quote a whole engine. I get the screenshot of that quote two or three times a month. So before you sign anything: that tick is almost certainly an MDS lifter going, and on most of these it does not need an engine. It needs the right parts and a guy who's done it enough times to do it once.

I'm Fares. I'm a mobile mechanic out of Mississauga, and I do this exact job — 5.7 and 6.4 HEMI lifters and camshafts — in people's driveways across the GTA. Here's what's actually wrong, how bad it really is, and what it costs done right.

What the HEMI lifter tick actually is

The 5.7 and 6.4 HEMI both run MDS — Multi-Displacement System, Chrysler's cylinder deactivation. Under light load the computer shuts down four of the eight cylinders (1, 4, 6 and 7) to save fuel. It does that with special MDS lifters that have a little oil-pressure pin inside: when the solenoid sends pressure, the pin lets the lifter collapse and the valve stops opening.

Here's the problem. Those MDS lifters ride on the cam on a tiny roller bearing, and that roller seizes. Once it stops spinning, it stops rolling over the camshaft lobe and starts skidding across it. Metal-on-metal, every revolution. That skid is the tick you hear. Leave it long enough and it wipes the lobe flat — the cam is toast and the shavings go straight into your oil, which is how one bad lifter turns into a few of them.

And the design doesn't do the engine any favours. The way the oiling is set up, the MDS lifter bore really only gets a proper feed of oil when the solenoid opens. At idle, when the system isn't active, those lifters are running close to starved — which is exactly when you hear the tick worst. That's not me guessing; that's the known weak point on these motors, and it's why it's almost always an MDS lifter and not a "normal" one.

On the 6.4 (392) — the SRT and Scat Pack Chargers and Challengers, the 2500 trucks — it's the same failure but it tends to gall the cam journal when it lets go, and the symptoms hit harder. That's the one dealers love to quote as an engine replacement. It usually isn't.

The real symptoms — what I listen for

People describe it a dozen ways, but it comes down to a short list. The earlier you catch it on this list, the cheaper it stays.

• A tick or tap at idle that quiets down as you bring the revs up. Classic early MDS lifter. This is the one you want to catch — text me a 10-second clip of it cold and I can usually tell you over the phone.
• A misfire light — P0300, or a cylinder-specific code like P0301 through P0308. Now the lobe is wearing and a valve isn't opening fully. The clock's ticking faster.
• Power loss under about 2,500 RPM, a rougher idle, sometimes a faint shudder. The motor's down a cylinder and doesn't want to pull off the line.
• An oil-pressure dip on deceleration, or the light flickering at a hot idle.
• Metal on the dipstick or in the oil. Fine glitter or flakes. That's the cam and lifter grinding themselves up. Stop driving.

Can it wait, or do I park it?

Straight answer, because that's the whole point of calling someone you trust:

If it's just a faint tick at idle that goes away with RPM, no check-engine light, nothing on the dipstick — you've got some time. Not all winter, but you're not stranded tonight. Book it, drive it gently, skip the highway hammering up the 401 and the heavy throttle.

The second you get a P0300-series misfire, feel a real power loss, or see metal in the oil — park it. Every kilometre after that is grinding more metal through the engine and pushing you from a lifter-and-cam job into a long block. This is the one place I won't tell you "ah, it'll be fine," because it genuinely won't. The honesty is the whole reason people call me instead of going back to the dealer.

What it actually costs — done right, at your door

This is the part you came for. The dealer quote is high for two reasons: they bill the engine out at a lift-and-flat-rate, and on the 6.4 they hedge toward a whole engine instead of doing the lifters. I do the lifters and cam properly, in your driveway, and I quote you a flat price before I touch anything — no shop, no surprise.

The spread depends on how far it's gone. Catch it as an early tick and we're replacing MDS lifters as a set, the cam, and the gaskets, and you're at the low end. If the lobe's already wiped and there's metal in the oil, there's more to clean up and the cam's definitely going, so it runs higher. Either way I drop the pan and flush out the metal so a stray flake doesn't kill the new lifter the week after I leave — that step is non-negotiable and a surprising number of jobs skip it.

Yes, it ends up well under the dealer. That's a byproduct of doing it without a building's overhead, not the pitch. The pitch is that it gets done right, once, by the same guy who quoted it, at your place — and that I'll tell you if it's the rare one that genuinely does need more.

Why this job is better done at your door

A HEMI lifter job is the kind of repair where trust matters more than anywhere. It's a big number, the parts are buried, and you can't see the work happening. At a shop your truck disappears behind a bay door for three days and you get a phone call. With me, it sits in your driveway, you can come out and look at the old cam and the seized lifter I pull out of it, and the person who quoted you is the person turning the wrench.

There's a GTA-specific wrinkle too. These trucks live through our winters, and road salt seizes bolts. The exhaust manifold bolts and accessory hardware on a ten-year-old Brampton work truck fight you the whole way — that's normal, I plan for it, and it's already in the flat quote. I'd rather break and replace a salt-welded bolt the right way in your driveway than have a flat-rate tech round it off in a rush.

About the MDS delete

Once we're in there, a lot of owners ask about deleting the MDS — swapping to non-MDS lifters, a matching cam, and a tune so the computer stops deactivating cylinders. On an out-of-warranty HEMI that's a legal, common, sensible move: it removes the exact part that keeps failing, and it's an emissions-legal performance choice, not a cheat. I'll walk you through the real trade-offs for your year and let you decide. Whether you keep MDS or delete it, you're getting fresh lifters and a clean cam.

HEMI lifter tick — FAQ

What does it cost to fix a HEMI lifter tick?

In your driveway, a 5.7 HEMI MDS lifter and cam job in the GTA usually runs $2,800 to $3,600, parts and labour, depending on whether the lobe's already wiped. A 6.4 / 392 runs $3,600 to $4,500 — more cylinders' worth of cleanup and a pricier cam. Dealers quote $4,500 to $9,000 and on the 6.4 sometimes a whole engine. Caught before the lobe's destroyed, it almost never needs an engine.

What causes the HEMI lifter tick?

The roller on an MDS (cylinder-deactivation) lifter seizes, stops spinning, and skids across the cam lobe instead of rolling over it — metal on metal. That skid is the tick. The lifter bore only gets a strong oil feed when the MDS solenoid opens, so at idle those lifters run starved, which is why it ticks worst at idle and why it's the MDS lifters that go, not the others.

Can I keep driving with a HEMI lifter tick?

A faint idle tick that quiets with RPM and no misfire light — you've got a little time, book it soon. A P0300-series misfire, a power loss under 2,500 RPM, or metal on the dipstick — park it. Past that point every kilometre grinds metal through the engine and risks turning a $3,000 repair into a long block.

Do you have to pull the engine to do the lifters?

No. The heads come off and the lifters and cam come out the front with the engine still in the truck — I do the whole thing in your driveway. I drop the pan to flush the metal and replace the MDS lifters as a set, not just the failed one.

Should I delete the MDS while it's apart?

On an out-of-warranty HEMI it's a legal, reasonable choice — non-MDS lifters, a matching cam, and a tune so the computer stops deactivating cylinders. It removes the part that keeps failing. I'll give you the honest pros and cons for your year; either way you get fresh lifters and a clean cam.

Ready to deal with it? Mobile engine repair · mobile diagnostic · how mobile service works · get a flat quote